Around New York In 18 Pizzas

| May 27, 2014 | 0 Comments

No Gravatar

When it comes to pizza wars, New York never backs down. From grimy joints selling by the slice to upmarket Italian pizzerias, New Yorkers can’t get enough of that delicious combination of dough, tomato sauce and mozzarella.


But while the locals might stay true to the same joint they’ve been visiting for years, where do you go for that authentic slice of pizza pie in the Big Apple?

We’ve picked our top 5 and the best of the rest. If we’ve missed your slice of pizza heaven let us know and we’ll be sure to pay a visit.

Note: All links will open a location in Google Maps!

1. Lombardi’s, Manhattan

Where else can we start but the first pizza joint in the whole of the United States? That’s right; Lombardi’s has been open since 1905 and has consistently been voted as one of the top pizzerias anywhere in the country. The pizza menu is small and classic, but it’s the original Neapolitan sauce that steals the show.

2. Pugsley Pizza, Bronx

Just round the corner from Fordham University, this is naturally a haunt for students. Many consider this one of the best pizza joints around, as the food is fantastic, but it’s the trumpet playing owner, Sal, that keeps the locals flocking back. Him and the karaoke, live music and occasional conga.

3. John’s of Bleecker Street, Manhattan

Open since 1929 (originally based in Greenwich Village), John’s is the all out experience and famed for their coal fired brick oven pizzas. The clientele are a loyal bunch, but that doesn’t mean you won’t be welcomed with open arms.

4. Paulie Gee’s, Brooklyn

Located in trendy, Greenpoint, Paulie Gee’s offers an authentic rustic experience (country music included) for the local hipster residents. Their thin crust oven pizzas are classic, but with a real New York twist – Beef Brisket and BBQ sauce anyone? They’ve also got a wide selection of vegan pizzas too – the hipsters will be happy!

5. Joe & Pat’s, Staten Island

With more than 50 years in the business this family team make classic Neapolitan style pizzas – the recipe brought over from Naples by Joe Pappalardo himself.

Best of the rest

6. Brother’s Pizza, Staten Islandsix massive shiny pizza ovens and some of the best pizza pie around. Worth the trip to Staten Island.

 7. Sacco Pizza, Hells’ Kitchen – open for 50 years, selling authentic NY thin crust.

 8. Nonna’s Pizzeria, Manhattan – the definition of a Grandma’s slice!

 9. Ray’s Pizza, Little Italy – the clue’s in the location.

10. Di Fara Pizza, Brooklynthe locals (and those from further afield) queue round the block for a slice from this small Midwood pizza joint.

 11. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, NYCThis chain of restaurants is a New York institution. Our favourite location? Nestled right under the Brooklyn Bridge.

12. Luigi’s Pizza, Manhattana favourite of actor Steve Buscemi.

 13. Koronet Pizza, Broadwaygreat location and the BIGGEST slices around. Seeing is believing.

14. Amore Pizzeria, Flushing classic Sicilian pizza at its best.

 15. Coals, Bronx – only open since 2004, this acclaimed pizzeria has had the food critics in awe, with a new location opening up in Port Chester.

16.  Speedy Romeo, Brooklynthey do things a little differently here!

17. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza, Manhattan (4 locations in NYC) – late night post party pizza anyone?

18. Percy’s Pizza, Greenwich Villagegreat location and slices for $1.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Category: Destinations, Food and Drink, New York, North America, Travel Information

About the Author ()

My name is Kelly Brindle and as well as being a mother of two young children, I am part of a great team at sharing our travel passion and experience. I have travelled to Australia, Far East, Canada, Middle East and Europe and love every aspect of travel! I have some great tips and advice entertaining the little ones on your next expedition too! Google+